An Argument Against Homeschooling Reasons Not To Homeschool An argument against homeschooling is that your child will "miss out" on all the things a school can provide. At first sight, it seems one of the most powerful arguments that might put you off homeschooling.
If it is broken, fix it. But if it cannot be fixed, replace it. The public schools are beyond repair. If it is not practical to replace the current system, then at least let those alone who wish to homeschool. Instead, encourage them and help them.
That may sound pretty revolutionary and, some will say, un-American. But more and more parents are homeschooling their children. The best-seller Megatrends states that a million children are being taught at home, but that is probably an exaggeration.
Yet several authors estimate thatfamilies engage in homeschooling. Advocates of homeschooling argue that all past attempts at reforming the public school have failed. Decentralization, An argument against home schooling classrooms, a return to the basics, values clarification, and an emphasis on counseling and programs directed toward the potential dropout, are but a few of the recent attempts to put Humpty-Dumpty together again.
Schools were even turned over to private corporations without any appreciable changes. Parents who homeschool their children have three basic complaints against public schools: Homeschool advocates claim that homeschooling overcomes these problems.
They argue that no matter whether the educational philosophy one holds is that schooling prepares for life or schooling is life, the homeschooled do better. Proponents also claim that private schools are nearly always similar to public schools, so the fundamental criticisms of public schools apply to private schools also, although to a lesser degree.
There are two ways to look at the arguments for homeschooling: Although the true merit of homeschooling probably is best told as a series of case histories, this paper will examine the many studies done on various aspects of homeschooling. Before we do so, however, we ought to look at the legal situation.
Almost every state permits some type of homeschooling. The stringent rules against it have usually fallen when challenged in court, unless the challenge was based on the claim that the state may impose no regulations whatsoever on any homeschool.
Existing state laws generally demand that homeschool children have a certain number of hours of schooling per year, and require parents to keep records of what is being done.
These records are to be inspected by the public school authorities. Academic Performance Let us now see how homeschooling compares to the public schools in academic performance.
According to a study in Alabama, elementary-age homeschooled children performed at comparable levels to public school children. Furthermore, the level of education of the teacher-parent was not related to the performance of the children, and children of parents without teacher certification did as well as those who had a certified teacher-parent.
Taking the First Step points out other studies which say basically the same thing: The teacher-parent, of course, has numerous texts, workbooks, videos, and materials to choose from, and when several families form a support group, an inexperienced parent can usually find answers to problems from other members of the group.
The children have the almost undivided attention of the teacher without the distractions of a classroom.
Homeschooled children also are much more likely to go to libraries, art, history, and science museums, and attend lectures and special events. Several families which homeschool will often engage in these activities together. The suggestions of educational reformers that teachers be better prepared, that classes be smaller, and that more money be spent will not bring about any substantial improvement in academic achievement, according to George Leonard.
He says that the cause of poor education is the nature of the public school today, and only drastic restructuring will work. Individualized education then can be much more effective than group education. Yet by and large, school is set up to humiliate publicly those who, for whatever reason, are unable to come up with the right answer when called upon.
By the time our children start to school, almost all of them have completed one of the most spectacular learning tasks on this planet: The mastery of spoken language with no formal instruction whatever. They have enjoyed a feast of high-intensity interaction with their teaching environment, which in this case comprises all the adults and other children around them.
Negative, not positive, socialization is the end product of most regular schooling, according to home-school advocates. The drastic increase in crimes perpetrated by pupils against teachers, pupils against pupils, and teachers against pupils is an indication of a system that has lost sight of its goals or cannot achieve them.
How can children be properly socialized in an atmosphere of fear and chaos? Peer dependency is also an example of negative socialization. It often prevents students from maturing, developing their own individual personalities, developing a moral code separate from that of the group, becoming self-reliant, and developing an acceptable work ethic.
One wonders about the viability of a system wherein most admit to cheating regularly and trying to get by with as little effort as possible. A student is not regularly encouraged to do his best, but just to be better than someone else.Dec 13, · An Argument Against Homeschooling A couple of our friends, some of Paige's cousins, and even a colleague who teaches with me at the high school are all seriously considering homeschooling their children.
that nothing need be said against the concept of home schooling, Civilizations being "inferior" materially is not quite . The Two Absolutely Best Arguments for Homeschooling. April 22, 16, Views. 4 minutes the two absolutely worst arguments against homeschooling, Walsh first just tells it like it is as he writes, “Dan, listen, I have to be real with you: this isn’t just a bad argument-it’s disturbing.
‘Help the system.’ Is this really a. In one study conducted in , parents indicated that the reason they chose homeschooling was for "religious or moral instruction" as the most important factor ("Research Center: Home Schooling"). According to one popular homeschool organization, Time4Learning, a Christian based Homeschooling program, there was .
In his post, Behold: the two absolutely worst arguments against homeschooling, Walsh answers one of his reader’s emails that accuses homeschool parents of not helping the “system” and the reader believes homeschooling deprives kids of learning proper socialization. Socialization - This is probably the biggest argument against homeschooling.
The truth is, though, that if you spend any time with a range of homeschool students, you will see that they are usually very well adjusted socially.
Argument Against Homeschooling. Parents' lack of teaching credentials is often presented as an argument against homeschooling. This article examines the issue of teacher qualifications, along with other proposed reasons why homeschooling is bad. Dec 13, · An Argument Against Homeschooling A couple of our friends, some of Paige's cousins, and even a colleague who teaches with me at the high school are all seriously considering homeschooling their children. That is the best argument against homeschooling for that individual. If that child/person learns better in a one on one environment and is not thriving in a traditional school setting, that is an argument for home education.
They spend time with siblings, parents, grandparents, and people in the community. Homeschooling cheats the system. In this case, he equates homeschooling to private school. When people who are able to pull their kids out of public school do, then the system fails.